An observational study to assess the therapeutic effectiveness of Brahmi capsule as experienced by the Ayurveda physicians across India during their clinical practice.
Abstract
Brahmi (Bacopa monnieri) is a traditional herbal medicine that has been in use since the time of the Vedic civilization for cognitive problems. Today the prevalence of Alzheimer’s disease among adults (almost 15% of adults of age 65 and above) and learning difficulties among children (between 5 to 15% among school going children) have grown exponentially high. As a result the usage of Ayush drugs related to adult and child psychological disabilities is getting more preference and among them Brahmi maintains its popularity as the most widely used brain tonic in the present era also.
Brahmi capsule is used for improving concentration and for managing the problems related to cognitive functions and speech. It is manufactured by Arya Vaidya Sala Kottakkal, Kerala in the form of capsules which contain 250 mg extract of Brahmi. For assessing the effectiveness and added benefits of it a cross sectional study was done among 220 Ayurvedic physicians who are using Brahmi capsule in their practice on a regular basis. Majority (202) of the physicians opined that they have used the medicine in all of the above mentioned indications either always or occasionally. Brahmi, which is described as Medhya(improves intellect), may directly work on micro-faculties such as Dhi( intelligence), Dhriti (retaining power of mind )and Smriti(memory) and thus helps in treating behavioral issues and learning difficulties. Bacosides are the triterpenoid saponins of prime importance which is found in Brahmi and they have shown the capacity to enhance nerve impulse transmission. The bacosides also promote the repair of damaged neurons by up-regulating neuronal synthesis and kinase activity. The bacosides also aid in the restoration of synaptic activity, which ultimately leads to proper nerve impulse transmission.
Brahmi capsule is also found to be effective in many conditions like anxiety, tremors, depression related to diabetes, post-surgical fine movement impairment, epilepsy, stammering etc. The present article is based on the survey conducted among the Ayurveda physicians in different parts of India, to assess the effectiveness and additional benefits observed during their clinical practice with Brahmi capsule.
Key words-Brahmi, Medhya, Bacosides, Swarya, Dhi
Section 1- Introduction
A person’s behavior is decided by a combination of factors like intelligence, memory, self-control and sound mental health etc. Each year, almost 15% of adults, of age 65 and above who have mild cognitive impairment develop Alzheimer’s disease over a period of time1. Learning disabilities are neurodevelopmental conditions that impair a person’s capacity for information acquisition, processing, or usage. Learning difficulties are a major problem for children in India and many other nations also. However, estimating the precise frequency of learning disorders can be difficult due to a number of factors, including different classifications, diagnostic standards, and study methodology. Various research have produced varying estimates of the prevalence of learning difficulties in India and according to several studies, the prevalence among school going children is between 5% to 15%.2
Brahmi (Bacopa monnieri) is a traditional herbal medicine that has been used by humans since the time of the Vedic civilization. Its native habitat is marshy places and it is a member of the Scrophulariaceae family. The Sanskrit term Brahmi is derived from Lord Brahma, the Hindu god of creation.
Brahmi maintains its popularity as the most widely used brain tonic and home remedy in the present era also. The consumers of this raw drug include children (even of neonatal age) to nonagenarians. Nowadays drugs related to child psychology or those which corrects learning disabilities is getting higher preference, and the whole world is reluctantly accepting the ancient wisdom of Ayurveda for enhancing memory, intelligence and cognitive functions.
Kashyapa samhita which is the prime text on Koumarabritya (Pediatrics) has given
Brahmi an important place among all Medhya drugs. In the available portion of
Kashyapa Samhita, Brahmi is mentioned in the first chapter, i.e. Lehaadhyaya.
Brahmi (Bacopa monnieri) is selected for the study here primarily due to its Medhya properties but it also shows Mehaghna (anti-diabetic) and Rasayana (rejuvenation) properties along with it. Several studies have also shown its multi-systemic action also.
Brahmi capsule of Arya Vaidya Sala, Kottakkal is prepared in the form of a capsule which contains 250 mg extract of the drug. It is found that Brahmi capsule helps in improving the concentration, intelligence and memory. It is also observed that Brahmi capsule helps to improve speech and sleep. For assessing the effectiveness and added benefits, a cross sectional study was done among 220 Ayurvedic physicians who are using Brahmi capsule in their practice on a regular basis.
The article has been organized in different sections as follows
Section-1- A brief introduction
Section 2- Methodology
Section 3- Observation, Analysis and interpretation of the survey
Section 4- Discussion
Section 5- Conclusion
Section 2- Methodology
Objective
To assess the effectiveness and added benefits of Brahmi Capsule
Materials:
Review of Literature: Compilation of references on Brahmi from Ayurvedic classics and journals.
Primary resources:
Bruhattrayi, laghutrayi with available commentaries, classical texts like Bhava prakasha Nighantu and Kayyadeva Nighantu etc.
Secondary resources:
Relevant modern literature, previous research works, MD and PhD theses, journals, published research papers and subject related data which is available online etc.
Developed questionnaire-Done face validity- Initially a questionnaire was developed and took expert suggestions. More than 90% of the contents were agreed by the clinical experts with more than 25 years of experience.
Methods
Plan of the study
Literature review of Brahmi –> Development of the questionnaire –>Survey done in different parts of country–> Analysis and conclusion
Primary and secondary resources were reviewed in the light of hypothesis and plan of study and necessary materials were compiled. Compiled materials were thoroughly studied, re-arranged and critically analyzed to provide the logical base for the study.
STUDY DESIGN: Descriptive Cross sectional study
STUDY POPULATION: In the present study, physicians practicing Ayurveda in different parts of India.
INCLUSION CRITERIA:
Age group: 25 – 80 years
Sex: Both sex included.
EXCLUSION CRITERIA:
Physicians who are not willing to participate.
SAMPLE SIZE:
It was calculated by using the following formula:
Z1-α/2 = 1.96
P = 60 %
d = 7 %
Expecting 60% prevalence of effectiveness of Brahmi capsule and considering a 7% margin of precision, the sample size is calculated as 196. Considering a drop out of 10%, the total sample size is considered as 215.
Conduct of survey: Survey was conducted by sending a request form and brief introduction about the study to the participants in the form of a google form.
DATA COLLECTION: Primary collection of data with a structured questionnaire though Google form
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Cross sectional study- Prevalence will be published in terms of frequency, percentage and Cumulative Percent. Diagrammatic representation of data by tables and figures like Pie diagram and bar diagram etc.
Sub analysis- Crosstabs, Chi-square.
Section-3-OBSERVATION, ANALYSIS and INTERPRETATIONS
Table 1 – Clinical Experience in years | |||||
Frequency | Percent | Valid Percent | Cumulative Percent | ||
Valid | 1-10 Years | 66 | 22.8 | 29.5 | 29.5 |
11-20 years | 91 | 32.3 | 41.8 | 71.4 | |
21-30 years | 41 | 14.4 | 18.6 | 90.0 | |
More than 30 years | 22 | 7.7 | 10.0 | 100.0 | |
Total | 220 | 77.2 | 100.0 |
Figure-1 – Clinical Experience in years
Out of 220 responses, 91(32.3%) physicians having 11-20 years of experiences. 41(15%) having more than 20 years. 22(8%) physicians having more than 30 years of experiences. Out of 220 physicians, 154(70.45%) physicians having more than 10 years of experiences.63 physicians having more than 20 years of experience.
Cross tabulation
Table-2-Clinical Experience in years and Effectiveness of Brahmi capsule | |||||
Count | |||||
Effectiveness of Brahmi capsule | Total | ||||
Mild | Moderate | Very Effective | |||
Clinical Experience in years | 1-10 Years | 3 | 28 | 35 | 66 |
11-20 years | 6 | 30 | 55 | 91 | |
21-30 years | 3 | 18 | 20 | 41 | |
More than 30 years | 0 | 11 | 11 | 22 | |
Total | 12 | 87 | 121 | 220 |
The cross tab shows that the effectiveness of Brahmi capsule and the clinical experience as follows. Out of 220 doctors, 121 physicians responded that Brahmi capsule is very effective and 87 doctors opined that it is moderately effective in its indications. 70.45%(154) of physicians having more than 10 years of experience suggested that Brahmi capsule is very effective in the management of memory dysfunction and other indications. (Very effective-action within 21 days, moderately effective-35 days, mildly effective-50 days or more)
Table-3-Chi-Square Tests | |||
Value | Df | Asymp. Sig. (2-sided) | |
Pearson Chi-Square | 17.800a | 6 | .007 |
The test for association of Effectiveness of Brahmi capsule and Clinical Experience in years got significant association with a P value 0.007(<.05).
Table-4-Frequency of Brahmi capsule in clinical practice | |||||
Frequency | Percent | Valid Percent | Cumulative Percent | ||
Valid | Never | 1 | .4 | .5 | .5 |
Rarely | 17 | 6.0 | 7.7 | 8.2 | |
Occasionally | 103 | 36.1 | 46.8 | 55.0 | |
Always | 99 | 34.7 | 45.0 | 100.0 | |
Total | 220 | 77.2 | 100.0 |
Out of 220 respondents, 99 (34.7 %) have reported that Brahmi capsule is used always in their clinical practice. 103 (36.1%) have reported that it is a drug of choice occasionally in their clinical practice. Out of 220 physicians, 202 physicians are using Brahmi capsule in their practice either always or occasionally.( Prescribes brahmi capsule at least once a week -Always, once in two weeks- occasionally, once in a month-rarely)
The Common Indication where Brahmi Capsule is used :
Table 5 : Cross Tabulation
Indications of Brahmi capsule | Total | |||||
Improving intelligence & concentration(I&C) and memory | Improving I&C, memory and sleep | Improving I&C, memory and speech
|
All indications | |||
In your clinical practice are you using Brahmi capsule | Never | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Rarely | 5 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 17 | |
Occasionally | 25 | 25 | 29 | 24 | 103 | |
Always | 24 | 33 | 26 | 16 | 99 | |
Total | 54 | 63 | 59 | 44 | 220 |
Majority (202) of the physicians opined that they were using the medicine in all of its proposed indications either always or occasionally. 44 physicians reported that Brhami capsule is effective in all of its indications. 63 physicians responded that it is giving positive result in three of its indications.
3) Indications of Brahmi capsule
Clinical Experience in years and Indications of Brahmi capsule
Table-6- Cross tabulation
Indications of Brahmi capsule | Total | |||||
Improving intelligence & concentration (I&C) and memory | Improving I&C, memory and sleep | Improving I&C, memory and speech | All indications | |||
Clinical Experience in years | 1-10 Years | 16 | 15 | 20 | 15 | 66 |
11-20 years | 22 | 28 | 20 | 21 | 91 | |
21-30 years | 10 | 12 | 14 | 5 | 41 | |
More than 30 years | 6 | 8 | 5 | 3 | 22 | |
Total | 54 | 63 | 59 | 44 | 220 |
Out of 220 responses, 154 physicians with more than 10 years of experience opined that it is effective in majority of its indications. Out of 4 major indications, 176 physicians responded that it is effective in three of its indications.
Table-7-Indications of Brahmi capsule
Indications of Brahmi capsule | Observations |
Improving concentration &intelligence | 184 |
Memory | 184 |
Improving speech | 67 |
Improving sleep | 92 |
All indications | 97 |
Improving concentration & intelligence and memory | 64 |
Improving concentration & intelligence , memory and speech | 117 |
Figure-3-Clustered column- Indications of Brahmi capsule
4) Ideal time of administration of Brahmi Capsule
Table-8- Time of administration of Brahmi Capsule
Empty stomach | 37 |
Before food | 16 |
After Food | 64 |
Bed time | 103 |
Figure-4- Ideal time of administration of Brahmi Capsule
Ideal time for administration of Brahmi Capsule and Indications of Brahmi capsule
Table-9-Cross-tabulation |
||||||
Count | ||||||
Indications of Brahmi capsule | Total | |||||
Improving I&C and memory | Improving I&C,memory and sleep, | Improving
I&C ,memory and speech |
All indications | |||
Ideal time for administration of Brahmi Capsule | Empty stomach | 7 | 10 | 14 | 6 | 37 |
Before food | 3 | 6 | 3 | 4 | 16 | |
After Food | 15 | 22 | 18 | 9 | 64 | |
Bed time | 29 | 25 | 24 | 25 | 103 | |
Total | 54 | 63 | 59 | 44 | 220 |
Cross tabulation shows that majority of the doctors (103-46.8%) opined that ideal time of administration of Brahmi capsule is at bed time. 64(30%) physicians reported that the ideal time of taking Brahmi capsule is after food.
5) Anupana
Table-10-Common Anupana
Arista ( Saraswarista) | 40 |
Gritha | 38 |
Ksheeram | 86 |
No Opinion | 25 |
Luke warm water | 10 |
Figure-5
Anupana and Indications of Brahmi capsule | ||||||
Table-11- Cross-tabulation | ||||||
Indications of Brahmi capsule | Total | |||||
Improving
I&C and memory |
Improving
I&C ,memory and sleep |
Improving
I&C ,memory and speech |
All indications | |||
Anupana | Arishta | 15 | 18 | 14 | 7 | 54 |
Gritha | 10 | 10 | 12 | 8 | 40 | |
Ksheeram | 21 | 25 | 22 | 22 | 90 | |
No Opinion | 8 | 5 | 7 | 6 | 26 | |
Luke warm water | 0 | 5 | 4 | 1 | 10 | |
Total | 54 | 63 | 59 | 44 | 220 |
Majority of the physicians (90) suggested that the anupana of brahmi capsule is ksheeram. The combination with saraswaristam is also suggested by 54 physicians.
6) Preferred dosage
Table-12-Dosage
Preferred dosage | Frequency |
Twice a day | 156 |
Once in a day | 45 |
Thrice in a day | 5 |
Figure-6
Majority (76%) of the physicians’ ideal dosage of the medicine is twice a day.
Preferred dosage of Brahmi capsule * Indications of Brahmi capsule | ||||||
Table-13- Cross-tabulation | ||||||
Indications of Brahmi capsule | Total | |||||
Improving
I&C and memory |
Improving
I&C ,memory and sleep |
Improving
I&C ,memory and speech |
All indications | |||
Preferred dosage of Brahmi capsule | Once in a day | 9 | 18 | 15 | 9 | 51 |
Twice a day | 42 | 45 | 43 | 34 | 164 | |
Thrice a day | 3 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 5 | |
Total | 54 | 63 | 59 | 44 | 220 |
7) Additional benefits
Table-14- Additional benefits
Additional benefits | Observations |
Yes | 216 |
No Opinion | 4 |
Figure-7
99% of the respondents opined that Brahmi capsule is having additional benefits like relieving anxiety, stress etc.
Additional Benefits and Effectiveness of Brahmi capsule | |||||
Table-15- Cross-tabulation | |||||
Effectiveness of Brahmi capsule | Total | ||||
Mild | Moderate | Very Effective | |||
Additional Benefits | Yes | 12 | 84 | 120 | 216 |
No Opinion | 2 | 2 | 0 | 4 | |
Total | 14 | 86 | 120 | 220 |
Table-15-Chi-Square Tests | |||
Value | Df | Asymp. Sig. (2-sided) | |
Pearson Chi-Square | 6.136a | 2 | .047 |
N of Valid Cases | 220 |
The test for association of Effectiveness of Brahmi capsule and its additional benefits is found be statistically significant with a p value 0.047.
Table-16- Additional Benefits and usage of Brahmi capsule in clinical practice | ||||
Additional Benefits | Total | |||
Yes | No Opinion | |||
In your clinical practice are you using Brahmi capsule | Never | 0 | 1 | 1 |
Rarely | 17 | 0 | 17 | |
Occasionally | 103 | 0 | 103 | |
Always | 97 | 2 | 99 | |
Total | 217 | 3 | 220 |
Table-17-Chi-Square Tests | |||
Value | df | Asymp. Sig. (2-sided) | |
Pearson Chi-Square | 74.310a | 3 | .000 |
N of Valid Cases | 220 |
The test for association of additional observations and the physicians with almost always usage of brahmi capsule is found to be statistically significant with a p value0.000.
Additional observations- It increases bowel movement in constipated patients. It is good in gastritis, premature graying of hair, excessive salivation or drooling of Saliva, stammering etc.
Section 4- Discussion
Improving concentration and intelligence.
Out of 220 responses, 184 physicians opined that brahmi capsule improves concentration and intelligence. Acharyas have mentioned that Medhya drugs are useful in the effective management of many conditions related with mind and Brahmi (Bacopa monneiri ) is a widely accepted Medhya drug. It is also included in the gana of Prajnasthapana(restoring intellect and knowledge), Samjya sthapana(Restoring sensation) and Shiro virechana. Therefore, Brahmi, may directly work on micro-faculties of such as Dhi, Dhriti, and Smriti which in turn will help in the management for treating behavioral issues and learning difficulties.
Bacopa, by the virtue of containing active constituents like bacosides, influences the synthesis and availability of the neurotransmitter, serotonin. Therefore, Bacopa helps to maintain neurotransmitter balance (Charles et al., 2011; Rauf et al., 2012a).Bacoside A shows a potent antioxidant effect in specific areas of brain. Bacopa is known to increase the activity of endogenous antioxidant SOD (Super oxide dimustate) & GPX (glutathione peroxide) in all the brain regions after a period of 21 days. Bacopa monnieri is also known to increase the antioxidant effect in hippocampus, a structure normally rich in memory neurotransmitter Acetyl choline. Bacopa has been found to reverse the drug induced depletion of Acetyl choline in the hippocampus.4
The bacosides promote the repair of damaged neurons by up regulating neuronal synthesis and kinase activity. The bacosides also aid in the restoration of synaptic activity, which ultimately leads to nerve impulse transmission (Singh and Dhawan, 1997). The nerve impulse transmission, plays a vital role in promoting healthy cognitive functions like attention span, focus, concentration, learning and memory.5
Effect on memory
Bacopa monnieri has been studied extensively at the central drug research institute Lucknow. According to the works at CDRI, Bacosides are the main phytochemical responsible for its action. Bacosides are attributed with capability to enhance the efficiency of nerve transmission thereby it strengthens memory and cognition.6
According to Kayyadeva nighantu, brahmi is medhya (improves intellect),rasayana(general rejuvenator),hridya(improves general mood), ayushya(increases longevity)7.
Among all the free radicals in living organisms, the most abundant are the super oxide radical and most destructive are the hydroxyl radical. These radicals appear to work together to induce degeneration by oxidizing membrane lipids, breaking DNA strands and damaging cellular proteins. The enzymatic defense system operates as a chain, starting from SOD and followed by the action of GPX and CAT.
Bacopa monnieri is found to increase SOD, CAT & GPX activities significantly throughout all the brain regions. Thus it possesses possible anti-aging benefits owing to its ability to alleviate oxidative stress in the striatal area of brain, which has good benefit in Alzheimer’s & Parkinson’s disease.
Study revealed that standardized Bacopa monnieri extract produced significant improvement on mental control, logical memory and paired associated learning during the 12-week drug therapy.8
Improving speech
67 doctors suggested that brahmi capsule is effective in improving speech (swarya). According to Bhava prakasha ,Kayya deva nighandu7 and Madanapala nighandu it is swarya.
Improving sleep
92 physicians opined that brahmi capsule improves the quality of sleep. Bacopa is considered to mediate the Gamma- Amino Buteric (GAB) aergic system.8 Gamma- Amino Buteric acid is an inhibitory neuro-transmitter that has been shown to possess sedative, anticonvulsive and anti- nociceptive effects.
Charaka has described the cause of sleep as due to the Klanta( fatigue) and Klama (mental fatigue) and the divorce of the sense objects from the senses.9Brahmi helps to lower stress and anxiety levels which in turn helps the mind to detach itself from the sense organs and thus leads to natural circadian rhythms which induce sound sleep.
Ideal time of administration of Brahmi Capsule
For any medicine to show its complete action on the vyādhi(disease), it needs to be administered in a proper kāla(time) with regards to doṣa (Functional elements of body) predominance, agni bala (digestive power), bala of rogi(strength of the patient) etc. That particular time is termed as auṣadha sevana kāla.ie, the ideal time for administration of medicine. Vāgbhaṭa has stated that ‘kālo bheṣaja yogakṛt, which means, kāla (the ideal time) fulfils the aim of administration of auṣadha (medicine).
Most of the physicians responded that the ideal time of administration of Brahmi Capsule is at bed time as the indications of Brahmi capsule is mainly related to brain functions.‘Niśi’
(night time administration of a drug) is ideal for the treatment of diseases related to parts of the body above shoulders.10
Preferred Anupana
Anupana is a substance which is taken along with or after the intake of Aahara (food) and oushadha drug11.Most popular anupana for Brahmi is milk. According to Vaghbhata, milk when digested properly, it is jivaniya (nourishes all the tissues), medhya (improves intelligence), sramahara (reduces fatigue). It is one of the most important foods to promote ojas (Essence of all physiological activities and health) 12. So administration of Brahmi with milk enhances its therapeutic effectiveness.
Additional benefits of Brahmi
Over and above the indications that has been mentioned, Brahmi is a well-known Rasayana dravya (regenerative drug), and Susruta mentions its usage in the Medha Ayushkamiya Adhayaya ,where it is mentioned that Brahmi helps in treating both Medha (intellect) and Ayus (Improves life expectancy) related problems. It implies that it acts at cellular levels, improving the innate healing potential and thus enhancing the life span by aging gracefully. Rasayana drugs like Brahmi have been shown to be antioxidants. Antioxidants play a definite role in improving the quality of life by preventing the excessive wear and tear phenomenon of cell structure and maintaining normal physiological activities.
Acharyas agree that Pragyaparadha( improper actions done physically, verbally and mentaly which leads to long standing unhealthy issues) is the primary cause of the emergence of most of the diseases. So, if a person’s Medha (intellect) is taken care of by regular usage of Brahmi, his/her positive decisions can help him in maintaining his/her personal and social life healthy on a long term basis. Kashyapa has recommended the use of Medhya Rasayana (substances that enhances a person’s intellect) like Brahmi soon after the birth itself to promote normal brain functioning. All acharyas have recommended the use of medhya rasayanas like Brahmi to promote intellect and also for the treatment of Manasika vyadhi (mental disorder) like Unmada, Apasmara etc 13
Conclusion
Future work recommendation
A comparative clinical trial for assessing the effectiveness and added benefits of Brahmi capsule.
Acknowledgement
Managing Trustee, Arya Vaidya Sala Kottakkal, Chief Executive officer Arya Vaidya sala, Kottakkal, and the whole physicians who involved in the survey
Conflict of Interest
None
Reference